Director: Zack Snyder
Genre: Action, Adventure
Starring: Henry Cavill, Ben Affleck, Gal Gadot, Jesse Eisenberg, Jeremy Irons, Diane Lane, Amy Adams, Holly Hunter
Superman and Batman. Two of the most iconic superheroes of all time, duking it out in a high-stakes battle. If you aren't familiar with the comic books, this concept might be something of a surprise to you: aren't Batman and Superman the good guys?
That's what a concerned mom at Target asked me the other day while I was stocking items in the toys section. My answer was, "Well, we don't really know for sure yet, but Batman and Superman don't quite see eye to eye in this movie." I really hope I don't see her again, because even after seeing the movie, I still can't tell you why Batman and Superman were fighting.
Before I get into the many issues plaguing the film, I'll talk about what I liked. First off, the obvious: Ben Affleck might be the quintessential Batman on film. He was perfect. Despite the huge (irrational) uproar over his casting, I think he was a great choice. Of course, I think Karl Urban would have been the best choice, and maybe could have been even better than Affleck. As it stands now, however, IMO Affleck is the best film Batman to date.
Of course, Henry Cavill is a fantastic Superman too. He proved himself in Man of Steel, and he does another fine job in this film. Gal Gadot does a serviceable job as Wonder Woman, but I think her performance is being a bit overrated by fans online.
Visually, there are a ton of great scenes in the film. You expect this from Zack Snyder, who's proven he can direct a fantastically dramatic action sequence, but ultimately is just a step above Michael Bay. At the beginning, the death of Bruce Wayne's parents still packs a bit of punch despite the fact that we've seen it plenty of times. Snyder gives us a unique take on this familiar scene.
Right after the opening credits, we see the Battle of Metropolis from Man of Steel, from Bruce Wayne's perspective. This is an epic, intense start to the film and is done really, really well. But from there, it starts to go downhill.
Almost immediately, the film begins to jump from scene to scene without any sense of coherence. The film throws so much at you in so little time you become bogged down in the details almost right out of the gate.
The introduction of Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor is when the film really starts to take a nosedive. Eisenberg is the biggest misfire casting perhaps ever in a superhero film. He is far too quirky, annoying, and obnoxious to have any sense of intimidation. His dialogue sounds like it was written by a pompous middle schooler who thinks he's a lot more intelligent than everyone else, and it's so ridiculously complex and filled with stupid metaphors I honestly couldn't understand a word he was saying, and it didn't help that I was distracted by his terrible performance. I get going for a new, different take on the character, but as many people have pointed out, he seems more like a Riddler or Joker than the dark, plotting, genius that is Lex Luthor. Lex is supposed to be an iconic, classic menacing, villain, and I don't think turning his character inside-out was a good idea at all.
The next two hours of the movie are a whirlwind of convoluted plot points that try way too hard to explain why Batman and Superman are fighting. Lex is attempting to orchestrate a battle between the two heroes, but I couldn't figure out why or what his goal was.
Batman's fight scenes are awesome, but he brutally murders people left and right. I don't have a huge problem with this, but it's a jarring change from Nolan's take on the character, especially since Batman uses guns to dispatch his foes on multiple occasions.
As I mentioned earlier, Wonder Woman is fine, but she has absolutely no place in the film. You could completely remove her character from the movie and still have the same exact movie. It seems as if she was included just to add more teasing for the eventual Justice League sequel.
It's painfully obvious that DC is trying desperately to catch up to Marvel as fast as possible, especially with the horrendously forced scenes in the middle of the movie that comic fans will recognize as "Knightmare" scenes. I don't read DC, so it didn't mean much to me, but I could recognize that they were teasing Darkseid, who is the big bad of the DC universe. To casual viewers, this scene must have been so out of left-field and so confusing. I can't imagine why they would include it, except to force even more teasing in an already overstuffed movie.
The final battle includes the classic Superman villain Doomsday, another unnecessary addition and waste of a fantastic storyline from the comics. The actual Batman v Superman fight is incredibly underwhelming. They punch each other around for a few minutes then become friends for...well, stupid reasons.
I don't know what went wrong in this film, but it's a massive disappointment. It's obvious that WB needs to can Zack Snyder and find someone more focused on good writing and coherence than big, bombastic action scenes. Despite the huge amount of money the film is bound to make, I hope WB listens to fan complaints and tries to improve their future films.
Verdict: 2/5
Before I get into the many issues plaguing the film, I'll talk about what I liked. First off, the obvious: Ben Affleck might be the quintessential Batman on film. He was perfect. Despite the huge (irrational) uproar over his casting, I think he was a great choice. Of course, I think Karl Urban would have been the best choice, and maybe could have been even better than Affleck. As it stands now, however, IMO Affleck is the best film Batman to date.
Of course, Henry Cavill is a fantastic Superman too. He proved himself in Man of Steel, and he does another fine job in this film. Gal Gadot does a serviceable job as Wonder Woman, but I think her performance is being a bit overrated by fans online.
Visually, there are a ton of great scenes in the film. You expect this from Zack Snyder, who's proven he can direct a fantastically dramatic action sequence, but ultimately is just a step above Michael Bay. At the beginning, the death of Bruce Wayne's parents still packs a bit of punch despite the fact that we've seen it plenty of times. Snyder gives us a unique take on this familiar scene.
Right after the opening credits, we see the Battle of Metropolis from Man of Steel, from Bruce Wayne's perspective. This is an epic, intense start to the film and is done really, really well. But from there, it starts to go downhill.
Almost immediately, the film begins to jump from scene to scene without any sense of coherence. The film throws so much at you in so little time you become bogged down in the details almost right out of the gate.
The introduction of Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor is when the film really starts to take a nosedive. Eisenberg is the biggest misfire casting perhaps ever in a superhero film. He is far too quirky, annoying, and obnoxious to have any sense of intimidation. His dialogue sounds like it was written by a pompous middle schooler who thinks he's a lot more intelligent than everyone else, and it's so ridiculously complex and filled with stupid metaphors I honestly couldn't understand a word he was saying, and it didn't help that I was distracted by his terrible performance. I get going for a new, different take on the character, but as many people have pointed out, he seems more like a Riddler or Joker than the dark, plotting, genius that is Lex Luthor. Lex is supposed to be an iconic, classic menacing, villain, and I don't think turning his character inside-out was a good idea at all.
The next two hours of the movie are a whirlwind of convoluted plot points that try way too hard to explain why Batman and Superman are fighting. Lex is attempting to orchestrate a battle between the two heroes, but I couldn't figure out why or what his goal was.
Batman's fight scenes are awesome, but he brutally murders people left and right. I don't have a huge problem with this, but it's a jarring change from Nolan's take on the character, especially since Batman uses guns to dispatch his foes on multiple occasions.
As I mentioned earlier, Wonder Woman is fine, but she has absolutely no place in the film. You could completely remove her character from the movie and still have the same exact movie. It seems as if she was included just to add more teasing for the eventual Justice League sequel.
It's painfully obvious that DC is trying desperately to catch up to Marvel as fast as possible, especially with the horrendously forced scenes in the middle of the movie that comic fans will recognize as "Knightmare" scenes. I don't read DC, so it didn't mean much to me, but I could recognize that they were teasing Darkseid, who is the big bad of the DC universe. To casual viewers, this scene must have been so out of left-field and so confusing. I can't imagine why they would include it, except to force even more teasing in an already overstuffed movie.
The final battle includes the classic Superman villain Doomsday, another unnecessary addition and waste of a fantastic storyline from the comics. The actual Batman v Superman fight is incredibly underwhelming. They punch each other around for a few minutes then become friends for...well, stupid reasons.
I don't know what went wrong in this film, but it's a massive disappointment. It's obvious that WB needs to can Zack Snyder and find someone more focused on good writing and coherence than big, bombastic action scenes. Despite the huge amount of money the film is bound to make, I hope WB listens to fan complaints and tries to improve their future films.
Verdict: 2/5






